Pizza by the Slice Near Me

Eleven slices

The slice category lists Regular Slice, Sicilian Slice, Marinara Sicilian Slice, Grandma Slice, Vodka Slice, White Slice, Fresh Mozzarella Slice, BBQ Chicken Slice, Buffalo Chicken Slice, Veggie Slice, and Chicago Style Slice. The photo is a folded pepperoni slice. Pepperoni is a topping, and the Regular Slice is the plain round slice on that list. Chicago Style is the menu's name for that slice. This page does not describe the crust beyond the name.

Whole pies live in a different category. If you need more than a couple of slices, order the matching pie: Regular, Sicilian, Grandma, Vodka, or White. A Grandma Slice is not a cut piece of the Sicilian.

Walk in, or order the slice ahead

The counter is at 413 New Dorp Lane, at the New Dorp Lane and Hylan Boulevard corner the rest of the site uses for directions. The shop is on New Dorp Lane. You can take a slice to a table, to the bar, or to the car. The room has 35 TVs if the slice is really an excuse to watch something.

Online ordering is the same slice list, for pickup or for an address checkout accepts. The family has made pizza since 1985. This location opened in 2020. Doors are open 11 AM to 1 AM every day.

Late slices

The full menu runs until 11 PM. From then until 1 AM, the order site shows the Extended Hours menu. That late list includes whole pies such as Regular, Sicilian, and Grandma. A late slice depends on that shorter menu still offering the slice you want, so look before you drive over for one specific name.

A party that needs pies rather than slices should start on the Halloween food page if that is the occasion, or on the party planner if the group wants the room. The phone is (718) 317-1010.

Questions