Grandma Pizza vs Sicilian

Four squares, not two

The style essay on grandma versus Sicilian already explains thickness and sauce. This post is the order. Bravo lists Grandma and Grandma Slice. It also lists Sicilian, Marinara Sicilian, Gluten Free Sicilian Pie, Sicilian Slice, and Marinara Sicilian Slice. If you only remember 'the square one,' you still have to pick a name.

There is no gluten-free grandma and no gluten-free Sicilian slice. The gluten-free square is the Gluten Free Sicilian Pie. A round Regular pie is the other default when nobody wants a square.

Pie or slice

Order the pie when the square is for a table or a house. Order the slice when you are at 413 New Dorp Lane and want one piece. Grandma Slice and Sicilian Slice are both on the slice list, next to Regular, Vodka, and White. They are not interchangeable. A Grandma Slice is not a corner of the Sicilian.

Toppings are add-ons on the pie pages: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and the rest, including half the pie. The prices stay on the order site. This post does not repeat them.

Where the decision happens

The shop is at 413 New Dorp Lane. The family has made pizza since 1985, and this location opened in 2020. Hours are 11 AM to 1 AM daily. The full menu runs until 11 PM. The phone is (718) 317-1010.

Read the style post if you want the usual difference between a thinner grandma and a thick Sicilian. Then come back here and tap the item whose name matches that difference.

Questions